Attempts by some hotels to stop Collective Management Organisations (CMOs) from licensing them for use of copyright works have failed.
A case in point is that of Bolton White Hotels, Johnwood Hotels Limited and Bolton Apartment vs Musical Copyright Society Nigeria Ltd/Gte (MCSN) in which the Federal High Court, Abuja Division, presided over by Justice Emeka Nwite, ruled that the action was grossly incompetent and therefore dismissed it.
The applicants, Bolton White Hotels, Johnwood Hotels Limited and Bolton White Apartments through Suit No: FHC/ABJ/CS/1840/2024 had obtained an interim order preventing MCSN from licensing them for use of musical works and sound recordings in their hotels.
The plaintiffs had asked the court to restrain MCSN whether by itself, servants, privies, successor-in-title, or any one or organisation/agency howsoever acting through them or on their behalf, from harassing, intimidating, threatening and compelling the plaintiffs to enter into contractual relationship with them by forcibly subscribing and procuring from the respondent, a copyright licence, which the plaintiffs do not need for the transaction of their business.
The applicants also sought an interlocutory order of the court restraining the respondent (MCSN) whether by itself, servants, privies, successor-in-title or anyone or organisation/agency howsoever acting through them or on their behalf from forcing or compelling the plaintiffs to submit to their demands to alltogether pay the sum of N64,403,634.57 for which there is no basis.
In addition, the applicants want the court to restrain the respondents from carrying on any action whatsoever and howsoever to hurt/harm, embarrass or be detrimental to the applicant’s business, reputation/integrity and incessant allegation of copyright infringement, and a daub of criminal liability for not subscribing to their copyright license.
The applicants based on their action that having subscribed or paid subscriptions to PayTV, they require no further licence to use music received through PayTV in their hotel business.
In reaction to the Motion on Notice, the respondent’s counsel on February 3, 2025 filed 34 paragraphs counter affidavit and formulated a sole issue for determination, to wit: Whether having regard to the circumstance of the case, the applicants are entitled to the reliefs sought.
However, after the arguments, Justice Emeka Nwite agreed with the counsel to the respondent and found the suit unmeritorious and consequently struck out the application.
In a similar suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1577/2024, another Federal High Court Judge of the Abuja Division shot down an attempt by Reiz Continental Hotels to prevent the Audio Visual Rights Society (AVRS) from licensing it for the use of works in its repertoire.
The court presided over by Justice Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu ruled that hotel owners and operators must seek and obtain license of the right owners before using any copyright works in their hotel business, even if such works were sourced from or supplied by a subscription-based PayTV.
In dismissing the suit, Justice Egwuatu affirmed that Reiz Continental Hotels is obligated to seek for and obtain the licence of right owners before it can use any of the copyright works in their hotel business, even if such works were sourced from or supplied by subscription-based PayTV such as DStv or Multichoice.
Leave a comment